Why members lapse and how a breed club can keep renewals on track
Most members who lapse did not decide to leave. They forgot, never got a clear reminder, or were unsure whether they had already paid. Keep one membership list that both the treasurer and the secretary trust, send reminders on a fixed calendar before and after the due date, write the grace period into the bylaws, and tell members plainly what lapsing costs them.

On this page
This guide is for the treasurer, membership secretary and board of a breed club or registry who chase renewals by hand every year. By the end you will have a short list of reasons members lapse, a renewal calendar you can adopt at the next board meeting, wording for what a lapse affects, and a plan for welcoming lapsed members back.
Why do members let their membership lapse?
Usually for ordinary reasons, not because they are unhappy with the club. Research from the association world points the same way: lapsed members tend to be disinterested rather than disgruntled, and the top stated reasons are not seeing the value in membership and forgetting to renew [4].
The common causes for a breed club look like this:
- They forgot. "Forgot to renew" regularly appears among the top five reasons members give for not renewing [5].
- They thought they had paid. Some members believe the bill was settled, or the invoice went to the wrong person [5]. In a club, that often means a renewal notice went to an old email address or to the other half of a household membership.
- The value was unclear. If the only contact a member had all year was the renewal notice, it is hard for them to say what the dues bought.
- Payment was awkward. A check mailed to a treasurer who changed last spring, or a form that has to be printed and posted, is enough to stall a busy member.
- Nobody reminded them. One notice in the autumn and silence afterwards leaves a lot to chance.
None of these need a dramatic fix. They need a dependable routine.
Who should hold the official membership list?
One list, kept in one place, that both the treasurer and the membership secretary update. When the treasurer records payments in a spreadsheet and the secretary keeps the roster in another, the two drift apart within a season, and members get conflicting answers about whether they are paid up.
To settle it:
- Name the record. The board votes on which list is the official record of membership status. Write that decision into the minutes.
- Give each person a clear job. The treasurer marks payments received. The secretary marks new members, resignations and address changes. Both work in the same record.
- Record the paid through date, not only "paid". A date answers the question a member actually asks: am I current, and until when?
- Reconcile once a month during renewal season. Compare deposits against the list so that a payment never sits in the bank without being credited to a member.
If a member asks whether they are paid up, the answer should take one lookup, not an email chain between two officers.
What should a renewal calendar look like?
A fixed sequence of reminders that starts before the due date, continues after it, and ends at the date your bylaws say membership lapses. Many breed club bylaws already set those anchor dates for you.
Published bylaws show the range. The Labrador Retriever Club makes dues payable by January 1, treats a membership as lapsed if dues are unpaid 90 days into the fiscal year, and lets the board grant a further 90 days in meritorious cases [1]. The Weimaraner Club of America sends each member a dues statement in October, makes dues payable by December 1, and treats membership as lapsed 30 days into the fiscal year, with a possible 60 days of extra grace [3]. The Israel Canaan Dog Club of America sets payment by January 1 and lapse after April 1 [2].
Here is a sample calendar built on a January 1 due date.
Example data: Alder Vale Registry renewal calendar
| When | What goes out |
|---|---|
| November 1 | Renewal notice with the amount, how to pay and what membership includes |
| December 1 | First reminder to anyone not yet paid |
| January 1 | Due date reminder |
| February 1 | Past due notice that names the grace period end date |
| March 15 | Final notice, ideally a personal note or phone call from an officer |
| April 1 | Grace period ends; status changes to lapsed |
Whatever dates you choose, put the grace period in the bylaws rather than leaving it to habit. A written rule protects the treasurer from awkward judgment calls and makes the board's decision on extensions consistent from one member to the next.
How can the club make paying dues straightforward?
Remove every step between the reminder and the payment. Each extra step is a place where a member puts the task down and forgets it.
- Put the amount and the method in every message. A reminder that says "dues are due" without saying how much or where to pay creates another task.
- Offer more than one way to pay. Some members prefer to mail a check, while others would rather pay online. Accept both if the board can manage it.
- Keep the mailing address current. When the treasurer changes, update every form, page and template on the same day.
- Send a receipt. A receipt with the paid through date ends the "did I pay?" question before it starts.
- Handle household and junior memberships clearly. Say who receives the notice and who is covered by the payment.
What does lapsing affect, and how should the club say so?
Say exactly what changes, in plain words, before the member lapses rather than after. A member may not know what they lose until they try to use it.
Voting is the most common consequence written into bylaws. The Labrador Retriever Club and the Weimaraner Club of America both bar anyone whose dues are unpaid as of a meeting date from voting at that meeting [1] [3].
Your club may tie other things to membership as well, such as member rates on registrations, eligibility for club shows or awards, a place on the breeder referral list, or the newsletter. Check your own bylaws and policies, then list every one of them in the past due notice.
Example data: Alder Vale Registry past due notice
Your membership with Alder Vale Registry will lapse on April 1. After that date you will not be able to vote at the annual meeting, member registration rates will no longer apply, and your listing on the breeder referral page will be removed until you renew.
That kind of sentence is not a threat. It is information the member needs to make a decision.
Do not remove privileges a member still holds. If your bylaws grant a grace period, the member stays in good standing until it ends, so time any status change to the date the bylaws set.
How should the club welcome lapsed members back?
Make returning simple, keep inviting them, and follow the reinstatement rule in your bylaws. Association research suggests that success with lapsed members depends on how long you keep offering them chances to renew and how well you understand what they care about [4]. Yet nearly 80 percent of associations in one recent survey had no formal process for reengaging lapsed members [5].
- Know your reinstatement rule. The Israel Canaan Dog Club of America, for instance, asks a member who lapsed for a year or less to pay the lapsed and current dues and write to the board, and requires a new application after a longer lapse, with board approval in either case [2]. Whatever your rule is, put it on the membership page.
- Contact them once after lapse. A short note saying the club would like them back, with the reinstatement steps, costs little.
- Mention what they were involved in. If a member showed every year or served on a committee, say so. Engaging people on what they care about gets a better response [4].
- Ask why, without pressure. One question on why they did not renew tells the board whether the problem was value, cost or a missed reminder.
- Keep them on general mailings where your policies allow. Show results and event notices remind people why they joined.
If the board is weighing new software for the registry's records, the registries page describes what Breed Ledger offers registries.
Key takeaways
- Most lapses come from forgetting, unclear value, awkward payment or a missing reminder, not from members choosing to leave.
- Keep one official membership list with a paid through date, shared by the treasurer and the membership secretary.
- Adopt a written renewal calendar with reminders before and after the due date, and put the grace period in the bylaws.
- Tell members in plain words what lapsing affects, such as voting, member rates and show eligibility, before it happens.
- Invite lapsed members back with a clear reinstatement rule and at least one personal contact.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a grace period be?
There is no single standard. Published breed club bylaws range from 30 days after the start of the fiscal year to 90 days, often with a board option to extend in meritorious cases [1] [3]. Choose a length your officers can manage and write it into the bylaws.
Can a member vote during the grace period?
Check your bylaws. Some clubs bar anyone whose dues are unpaid as of the meeting date from voting, even if their membership has not yet lapsed [1] [3]. If your annual meeting falls in renewal season, remind members of that rule in the notice of meeting.
Should the treasurer or the secretary send renewal reminders?
Either can, as long as both work from the same list and the board has agreed who sends what. The Weimaraner Club of America, for example, assigns the October dues statement to the treasurer [3].
What if a member says they paid but the list says otherwise?
Ask for the date and method of payment, check the deposit records, and correct the list if the payment is found. A monthly reconciliation during renewal season catches most of these cases before the member notices.
Sources
- The Labrador Retriever Club, Inc., "Constitution & Bylaws" (as of November 2025), https://thelabradorclub.com/?p=305 (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
- Israel Canaan Dog Club of America, Inc., "Constitution and Bylaws" (amended July 3, 2009), https://icdca.org/ICDCA/ICDCAxCBLxUKC.html (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
- Weimaraner Club of America, "Constitution and By-Laws" (undated), https://weimaranerclubofamerica.org/bylaws.php (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
- ASAE, "Baby, Come Back! How to Win Back Lapsed Members and Why You Should" (May 2, 2023), https://asaecenter.org/resources/articles/an_plus/2023/5-may/baby-come-back-how-to-win-back-lapsed-members-and-why-you-should (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
- Associations Now, "Report: Associations Struggling With Member Engagement" (February 3, 2026), https://associationsnow.com/2026/02/report-associations-struggling-with-member-engagement/ (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
