Skip to content
Book a demoStart your free trial
Governance and policy

Open, closed and appendix studbooks: what a board should know first

The short answer

A closed studbook only accepts animals whose parents are already registered. An open or partly open book admits outside animals under written conditions, and a grading up register lets crossbred or unrecorded animals breed toward full status over several generations. Any change works only if the registry can mark each animal's section and generation, apply eligibility rules the same way every time, and record inspections.

Dusty Mumphrey
Founder, Breed Ledger. Senior engineer. Active multi-species breeder.

Published 9 min read

Illustration of three studbooks: an open book with a blank row ready for a new entry, a closed book locked with a clasp, and a closed book with a green appendix tab sticking out of its pages.

This is for registrars, secretaries and board members of a small breed whose members have started asking about outcrossing or reopening the book. By the end you will know the four main options, what real registries have done, the records each option needs, and a sequence for running the decision so members trust the result.

What do closed, open and appendix studbooks actually mean?

The terms describe who can enter the book and on what terms. Most registries use one of four models, and many mix them.

  1. Closed studbook. An animal is eligible only if its sire and dam are already registered in the same book. Nothing new enters, so the gene pool can only stay the same size or shrink.
  2. Open studbook. Animals from outside the registered population can be entered if they meet written criteria, such as inspection scores or approved outside breeds.
  3. Partly open or time limited opening. The book stays closed in general but admits a defined group of animals for a set period, then closes again.
  4. Appendix, supplementary or grading up register. Outside animals enter a separate section, not the main book. Their descendants move up section by section as they are bred back to fully registered animals, until they qualify for the main book.

The UK government's standards for approved breeding programmes describe the last model directly. A supplementary section can hold breeding animals whose pedigree cannot be traced, and their offspring "may become recognised as pedigree" over time if conditions are met [1].

What have real registries done when the gene pool got too small?

Several well documented cases show each model in practice. They are worth reading in full before the board debates anything.

  1. Basenji, time limited opening. At the Basenji Club of America's request, the American Kennel Club agreed in August 2008 to open the Basenji stud book to dogs from countries with no AKC accepted registry. The book had been closed since 1990. Dogs had to be at least one year old at evaluation and imported from Africa after 1990, and each one went through the club's ten step process followed by a vote of the club's board and membership. The opening ran from January 1, 2009 to December 31, 2013 [2].
  2. Dalmatian, a single outcross followed by backcrossing. In 1973 a geneticist and Dalmatian breeder began a project with one Dalmatian and Pointer litter to bring back the normal uric acid gene, then backcrossed to Dalmatians for several generations [3]. The AKC registered the first dogs in 1981, then placed a hold after breeder objections. In June 2011 a strong majority of Dalmatian Club of America members voted in favour of registration, and in July 2011 the AKC board voted unanimously to accept the descendants into the stud book [3]. A separate report notes that after fourteen generations, more than 99.98 percent of these dogs' genes match a purebred Dalmatian's [4].
  3. Warmblood horses, an open book with graded sections. The Canadian Warmblood Horse Breeders Association keeps a Main Mare Book, a Mare Book, two Pre Mare Books and an Auxiliary Book. Registered Thoroughbred, Arabian or Anglo Arabian mares can enter Pre Mare Book II if they reach set inspection scores, and their daughters can move up as they are bred to approved stallions [5].
  4. Livestock, grading up through the female line. Under the UK standards, grading up for cattle, sheep, pigs and goats runs through the female line using main section males. A female whose dam and maternal granddam are in the supplementary section, and whose sire and grandsires are in the main section, becomes eligible for the main section [1].

None of these happened quickly, and the Dalmatian case shows how long a decision can stall when members are not brought along.

What records does each option require?

Every option except a fully closed book asks the registry to record more than parentage. If the records cannot carry the extra detail, the rules will not be applied consistently.

  1. Section or status on every animal. Each animal needs a field showing which book or section it sits in. The Canadian warmblood rules build this into the registration number itself, with a two character code for the stud book division at the end [5].
  2. Generation count from the outside ancestor. For grading up, the registrar has to know how many generations separate each animal from the foundation animal, on which side of the pedigree. The UK rules depend on exactly this: the dam and maternal granddam in one section, the sire and grandsires in another [1].
  3. Eligibility rules written as tests. Write each rule so two different registrars would reach the same answer: required parents' sections, minimum age, inspection score, any DNA requirement.
  4. Inspection results. If entry depends on conformation or health checks, store who inspected, when, the score and the outcome. The Canadian association requires minimum scores in each of six judged parts [5].
  5. Certificates that show status. Members, buyers and judges need to see an animal's status on its papers. The same association issues different coloured registration certificates depending on the dam's division [5].
  6. Dates for any opening window. A time limited opening needs a start date, an end date and a rule for animals already in the process when the window closes.
Tip

Before the vote, ask the registrar to pull five real pedigrees from the current records and work out by hand which section each animal would land in under the proposed rule. Gaps in the data show up fast.

How should the board run the decision?

Treat it as a rule change with evidence, consultation and a review date, not a single motion at one meeting. A clear sequence protects the board as much as the breed.

  1. State the problem in writing: current registrations, number of active sires, and any known health issue, using the registry's own figures.
  2. Choose the model the board is considering and write the draft eligibility rules in full.
  3. Ask the registrar to confirm the records can carry section, generation and inspection data.
  4. Publish the draft to members with a fixed comment period and at least one open meeting.
  5. Hold the vote under the method the bylaws require, such as a board vote, a member vote, or both.
  6. Set a review date, such as three or five years, with named measures to check at that review.

The Basenji process is a useful pattern because it combined written criteria with a vote on each individual dog [2]. The Dalmatian history is a useful warning: a decision made in 1981 without member agreement led to a hold that lasted about thirty years [3].

What should the board tell members?

Members mostly want to know three things: why, what changes for their own animals, and how long it lasts. Answer all three in plain language before the vote and again after it.

  1. Why. Share the evidence the board relied on, using the registry's own counts. Example data: "Alder Vale Registry recorded 41 litters last year from 9 sires."
  2. What does not change. Make clear that existing registrations keep their status. Members often fear their own animals will be devalued.
  3. How new animals will be marked. Show what a supplementary or appendix certificate will look like and how the section appears in the online records.
  4. How an animal moves up. Publish the exact generation and inspection rules, with a worked example.
  5. When the board will look again. Give the review date and what will be measured.
Warning

Do not let a rule take effect before the registrar can record it. An opening announced while the records still only hold "registered" or "not registered" creates disputes that are hard to unwind later.

If the board is weighing new software for the registry's records, the registries page describes what Breed Ledger offers registries.

Key takeaways

  • A closed book can only shrink; open, partly open and grading up models each add animals under different controls.
  • Real cases, from the Basenji opening to the Dalmatian backcross and livestock grading up, all relied on written criteria and separate marking of new animals.
  • Every option beyond a closed book needs section, generation and inspection data recorded for each animal.
  • Run the change as a process: written problem, draft rules, records check, member consultation, vote and review date.
  • Tell members why, what stays the same, how new animals are marked and when the board will review the decision.

Frequently asked questions

Does an appendix register mean those animals are purebred?

No. Animals in an appendix or supplementary section are recorded but sit outside the main book. Their descendants can qualify for the main book only after meeting the registry's generation and inspection rules [1].

How many generations does grading up usually take?

It depends on the registry's rules. Under the UK standards for cattle, sheep, pigs and goats, a third generation female bred from main section males becomes eligible for the main section [1]. Each registry sets its own count.

Can the board open the book for a limited time only?

Yes. The AKC Basenji opening ran for five years with fixed start and end dates [2]. Write the end date and the rule for pending applications into the decision itself.

Who should make the final decision?

Follow the bylaws. If they are silent, consider a member vote alongside the board vote, as the Basenji and Dalmatian clubs both used member votes before the kennel club acted [2][3].

Sources

  1. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, "Approved breeding programmes: standards for breed societies and organisations" (11 February 2022), https://www.gov.uk/guidance/approved-breeding-programmes-standards-for-breed-societies-and-organisations (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
  2. American Kennel Club, "American Kennel Club Opens Basenji Stud Book" (18 August 2008), https://www.akc.org/press-releases/american-kennel-club-opens-basenji-stud-book/ (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
  3. Veterinary Information Network (Tufts Canine and Feline Breeding and Genetics Conference), "The Dalmatian/Pointer Backcross Project: Overcoming 20th Century Attitude about Crossbreeding" (2011), https://vin.com/doc/?id=5101841 (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
  4. Whole Dog Journal, "An Update on Low Uric Acid Dalmatians" (17 December 2010, updated 24 April 2019), https://www.whole-dog-journal.com/health/an-update-on-low-uric-acid-dalmatians/ (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
  5. Canadian Warmblood Horse Breeders Association, "Stud Book Regulations and Breeding Program" (amended 12 April 2019), https://canadianwarmbloods.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/CWHBA-Stud-Book-Regs-clean-copy-Feb2020.pdf (external site), checked 2026-11-09.
Share this articleLinkedIn (external site)Email

About the author

Dusty Mumphrey

Written by

Dusty Mumphrey

Founder, Breed Ledger. Senior engineer. Active multi-species breeder.

Dusty builds Breed Ledger and breeds more than one species himself. He writes about why club records matter and what he is building next.

About Breed Ledger

Registries

See how Breed Ledger works for registries.

Registrations, certificates and records, run from one place.