Membership software
Breed Ledger beside WildApricot, ClubExpress and Join It.
A comparison written to be fair, for a club asking about dues, renewals and moving off a spreadsheet. Every cell for the three tools comes from their own public pages, checked on 2026-11-08.
In short
Who each fits.
WildApricot, ClubExpress and Join It are membership tools for many kinds of organization, and each fits a club whose records are members, dues, renewals, events and a member site.
Breed Ledger fits a breed club or registry that also registers animals, because registrations and certificates sit on the same records as members and dues.
Side by side
What each one lists.
| Capability | WildApricot, checked 2026-11-08 | ClubExpress, checked 2026-11-08 | Join It, checked 2026-11-08 | Breed Ledger |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who it is for | Member-based organizations; its Who We Serve menu lists Associations, Nonprofits, Chambers, Clubs, Charities and Chapters | Clubs and associations: "purpose-built software for clubs, associations, and membership-based groups" | Communities served include Professional Associations, Hobby & Social Clubs and Sports & Fitness Clubs, among others | Breed clubs, associations and registries of any species |
| Price, as each publishes it | By contacts managed, from 100 to 50,000 contacts; at 100 contacts $66.00/mo billed monthly, $59.40/mo pre-paid for 1 year, $56.10/mo pre-paid for 2 years | By member, billed monthly: up to 200 members, 42 cents per member and 20 cents for each secondary member, with a $24 Minimum Monthly Hosting Fee; 201 to 300 members, 38 cents and 18 cents; lower per-member rates continue to 1000 members. A one-time setup fee, merchant processing and extra-cost functions are also listed, amounts not read | By plan, billed monthly: Starter $29/mo, Total $99/mo, Extra $199/mo, Enterprise custom; yearly billing is 10% less; pricing also depends on member capacity | Priced per club or registry, never per member: Club is $119 a month or $1,190 a year, Registry is $299 a month or $2,990 a year, and Registry Plus starts at $599 a month. |
| Fees on online payments | Not stated on the pages read | Merchant processing is listed as an option, amount not read | "a service fee of 1.5%-3% (depending on your plan) on paid memberships and paid event registrations" | Breed Ledger takes no platform fee on club and registry payments. Stripe's own card fees are charged by Stripe to your club's account. |
| Dues and renewals | Member management lists "automated membership renewals and reminders"; its Clubs entry says "Software to manage your members' activities, dues, communications, events and more" | Membership Management: "Add, renew, and organize members with customizable data fields"; Payments & Accounting: "Collect dues, donations, and fees securely" | The Starter plan lists recurring payments and renewal reminders | Members pay dues online into your club's own Stripe account, monthly, quarterly or yearly, and the roster shows who is current |
| Events | Event management: event listings, registration forms, online event payments and waitlists | Event & Calendar Tools | Paid event registrations; check-in features on the Total plan | Yes, when your club turns on events: members enter online, class fees are paid through Stripe, and results go on a public results page |
| Club website and member site | A branded members-only website, a member portal and an online membership directory | Website Builder | A member directory on the Total plan; custom domains on the Extra plan | Yes: the club website, and a public registry when your club turns it on |
| Animal registry, pedigrees and studbook | Not stated on the pages read | Not stated on the pages read | Not stated on the pages read | Yes: registrars and admins decide registration requests in a queue, unless your club approves registrations on payment; your club sets its number format; the registry reads from the same member records as dues |
| Certificates with a public verify page | Not stated on the pages read | Not stated on the pages read | Digital membership cards on the Total plan; registration certificates not stated on the pages read | Yes, when your club turns on certificates: the verify page says valid, with the current version, or revoked |
| Getting started | "Try Free for 60-Days with $0 Setup", no credit card required, with onboarding coaches described as "no extra cost" | Start a Free Trial Website or Request a Demo | "No credit card required", "No setup cost", "No hidden fees" | Book a demo. Dusty Mumphrey, Breed Ledger's founder, goes over your club's needs and what migrating would look like |
| Moving your records | Not stated on the pages read | Not stated on the pages read | Not stated on the pages read | Dusty Mumphrey moves your records with you, currently free. Send your spreadsheet as it is and he maps your columns with you |
Where a page says nothing about a row, the cell says so, and that is not the same as the tool lacking it.
Checked on 2026-11-08.
Fit
Where each fits.
- Your organization registers no animals, and members, dues, events and a member site are the whole job
- You want to try a tool first: WildApricot lists a 60-day free trial and Join It lists no credit card required
- You want a price set by your contact count or member count, which WildApricot and ClubExpress publish
- Registrars decide registration requests, and your club issues certificates anyone can verify
- Membership, dues and the registry share one set of records, and events join them when your club turns them on
- Your club or registry covers any species, and you want one price for the organization, never per member
Questions
Questions about membership software and Breed Ledger.
Can a breed club run dues and renewals on WildApricot, ClubExpress or Join It?
What do WildApricot, ClubExpress and Join It cost, and what does Breed Ledger cost?
Do WildApricot, ClubExpress and Join It include an animal registry?
What fees come out of dues payments?
Can a club move off a spreadsheet to Breed Ledger?
Does Breed Ledger work for more than one species?
Switching
Moving off a spreadsheet or another tool.
I move what you can export, with you, and you can run both until your board is ready, for as long as your old system stays available. How migration works
Read next
More to compare.
Pricing
How plans are priced for clubs and registries.
Membership
How applications, renewals and dues work for a breed club.
Payments
How dues and fees are paid into your club's own Stripe account.
Other comparisons
How Breed Ledger compares with pedigree databases, spreadsheets and other registry software.
Start your club
Compare with your own member list.
Bring the spreadsheet or export your club runs on now to the demo.
Last updated